For Old Recipe Page,
click Here
Sunday, April 12, 2026 2:03 AM
Recipe Menu
Home
Newest Recipes
Most Popular Recipes
Highest Rated Recipes
Admin Login
Submit a Recipe
Browse Recipe Categories
»
Appetizers
(17)
»
Barbeque & Dutch Oven
(8)
»
Beverages & Drinks
(15)
»
Breads - Quick - Dinner Breads
(16)
»
Breads - Quick - Pancakes & Waffles
(9)
»
Breads - Quick - Sweet Breads
(27)
»
Breads - Yeast - Breads
(14)
»
Breads - Yeast - Rolls
(15)
»
Breads - Yeast - Sweet Rolls
(6)
»
Canning - Fruits & Vegetables
(0)
»
Canning - Jams, Jellies, Preserves & Marmalades
(1)
»
Canning - Pickles, Relishes & Sauces
(7)
»
Desserts - Bars
(18)
»
Desserts - Brownies
(7)
»
Desserts - Cakes & Cupcakes
(43)
»
Desserts - Candies
(35)
»
Desserts - Cobblers, Crisps, etc.
(11)
»
Desserts - Cookies
(50)
»
Desserts - Frostings, Toppings, Fillings & Sauces
(27)
»
Desserts - Other
(10)
»
Desserts - Pies, Tarts, Turnovers & Pastries
(42)
»
Desserts - Puddings & Custards
(27)
»
Eggs & Cheese
(4)
»
Fish & Shellfish
(5)
»
Fruits
(0)
»
Meats - Beef
(22)
»
Meats - Pork
(5)
»
Meats - Sauces, Gravies, Marinades & Glazes
(5)
»
Misc Unsorted
(1)
»
Misc. Syrups & Sauces
(10)
»
Pastas
(19)
»
Poultry
(26)
»
Poultry - Stuffings & Dressings
(7)
»
Rice Dishes
(14)
»
Salad & Salad Dressings
(26)
»
Sandwiches, Pizzas, etc
(4)
»
Soups, Stews, Chilis, etc.
(24)
»
Vegetables
(18)
»
BF-Breads
(31)
»
BF-Desserts
(95)
»
BF-Main Dishes
(46)
»
BF-Miscellaneous
(25)
»
BF-Salads
(18)
»
BF-Side Dishes
(16)
»
GJ-Breads & Cake Mixes
(10)
»
GJ-Cakes in Jars
(8)
»
GJ-Cookies
(38)
»
GJ-Dips, Seasonings & Beverages
(8)
»
GJ-Soups & Hearty Fare
(7)
»
KS-Edible Clays & Doughs
(13)
»
KS-Inedible Modeling Clays & Doughs
(45)
»
KS-Paints, Bubbles, Crayons & Chalk
(17)
»
KS-The Fun Stuff (Gunk, Gak, Glubber, Etc)
(11)
Search Recipe
All Category
Appetizers
Barbeque & Dutch Oven
Beverages & Drinks
BF-Breads
BF-Desserts
BF-Main Dishes
BF-Miscellaneous
BF-Salads
BF-Side Dishes
Breads - Quick - Dinner Breads
Breads - Quick - Pancakes & Waffles
Breads - Quick - Sweet Breads
Breads - Yeast - Breads
Breads - Yeast - Rolls
Breads - Yeast - Sweet Rolls
Canning - Fruits & Vegetables
Canning - Jams, Jellies, Preserves & Marmalades
Canning - Pickles, Relishes & Sauces
Desserts - Bars
Desserts - Brownies
Desserts - Cakes & Cupcakes
Desserts - Candies
Desserts - Cobblers, Crisps, etc.
Desserts - Cookies
Desserts - Frostings, Toppings, Fillings & Sauces
Desserts - Other
Desserts - Pies, Tarts, Turnovers & Pastries
Desserts - Puddings & Custards
Eggs & Cheese
Fish & Shellfish
Fruits
GJ-Breads & Cake Mixes
GJ-Cakes in Jars
GJ-Cookies
GJ-Dips, Seasonings & Beverages
GJ-Soups & Hearty Fare
KS-Edible Clays & Doughs
KS-Inedible Modeling Clays & Doughs
KS-Paints, Bubbles, Crayons & Chalk
KS-The Fun Stuff (Gunk, Gak, Glubber, Etc)
Meats - Beef
Meats - Pork
Meats - Sauces, Gravies, Marinades & Glazes
Misc Unsorted
Misc. Syrups & Sauces
Pastas
Poultry
Poultry - Stuffings & Dressings
Rice Dishes
Salad & Salad Dressings
Sandwiches, Pizzas, etc
Soups, Stews, Chilis, etc.
Vegetables
Home
»
Desserts
»
Key Lime Pie
Recipe A-Z:
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
Y
Z
Save to favorite
Print this recipe
Email this recipe
Key Lime Pie
Rating:
(
3.1
) votes
21
Rate this recipe
1
2
3
4
5
General Information
Category:
Desserts
Date Posted:
9/27/2009
Author:
Elaine Cope
Hits:
298
Comments:
Prep Time:
Total Time:
Serves:
Ingredients
Makes 1 - 9 inch pie
2 Eggs, separated
1 cup plus 2 Tbl. Sugar
½ cup Milk
1 Tbl. Gelatin
½ cup Key Lime Juice
1 tsp. Grated Lime Rind
2 cups Heavy Cream
1 - 9 inch baked Graham Cracker Crust
1 tsp. Vanilla
Garnish: Lime Twists
Instructions
1. Set out the eggs and milk so that they reach room temperature. The custard will set faster and the whites will whip higher, if the chill is off these ingredients.
2. In the top of a double boiler, mix the egg yolks, ½ cup sugar, and milk. Place over simmering hot water. Do not allow water to touch bottom of pan holding the yolks. Stir constantly, using a wire whisk, 10 to 15 minutes, until eggs form a loose, frothy custard sauce. (Thick enough to coat a spoon.)
3. Mix together the gelatin, lime juice, and lime rind. Let sit 1 to 2 minutes to soften, then add to warm custard. Cook and stir the custard about 1 minute, until the gelatin is dissolved and well blended. Remove pan from heat and cool mixture down to room temperature.
4. While custard is cooling whip 1 cup heavy cream into soft but heavy peaks. This will make 2 cups whipped cream. Set aside briefly.
5. Place egg whites in a clean dry copper or stainless steel bowl. Beat medium speed until foamy, then raise speed and beat until soft peaks form. Begin beating in ½ cup sugar, a tablespoon at a time, until peaks become firm and satin-like.
6. If at this time, the custard has not reached a consistency that resembles very loosely hipped cream hasten the process by placing the custard pan in a bowl of ice water. Stir the custard constantly until thickened properly. Watch carefully that you do not go beyond this consistency or the custard will have to be warmed to resoften, then cooled again.
7. Fold the w cups whipped cream into the properly thickened egg-custard mixture. Then gently fold in the stiff egg whites. Pour the mixture in to prepared graham cracker crust.
Chill until firm. When firm, ship remaining cup of cream with 2 tablespoons of sugar and the vanilla until soft peaks from.
8. Spread cream on top of lime filling, mounding in the center. Chill well before serving and garnish with twisted lime slices.
Other
Desserts
recipes you might be interested
»
Buttery Cashew Brittle
»
Blackberry Cheesecake with Shortbread Crust
»
Easy Oatsies
»
Heavenly Yum Yum Dessert
»
Almond Roca - English Toffee
»
Vanilla Custard Pudding
»
Brownies
»
The Philly 3-Step Cheesecake Recipe
»
Banana Spice Cookies
»
Ice Cream
»
Hostess Twinkies
»
Snicker Doodles
»
Summer Berry Brownie Torte
»
No-Bake Fudge Cookies (Boiled Cookies)
»
Chocolate Fudge